Bugzilla – Bug 1142370
Untested laptop multimedia keys, please report success or failure to eric.piel@tremplin-utc.net
Last modified: 2020-12-04 08:07:38 UTC
Created attachment 811190 [details] journal On each boot I see this message in the journal: Untested laptop multimedia keys, please report success or failure to eric.piel@tremplin-utc.net However nobody replies to that email address.
Could you give more hardware details? It's wistron-btns driver and it has a quirk table depending on the DMI, so we need to know your machine DMI table. Please upload the hwinfo output, at least.
Created attachment 811196 [details] service guide This is Acer TravelMate 2410. I am attaching the PDF of the service guide. I am hesitant to upload full hwinfo output because it contains too much uniqely identifying info (serial numbers etc) most of which is probably not even necessary. Could you please request the actual specific info which you really need (and which is safe to share in a public system like this one)?
At least the DMI information is needed. Please give the output of dmidecode.
Created attachment 811199 [details] dmidecode Here it is.
OK, thanks. And do all multimedia keys work as expected other than that message? As far as I read the code, the driver detects: help, power, prog1, prog2, mail, www, config, wifi, and bluetooth keys. If they do work, I'll submit the patch to upstream to turn off the test flag. Basically there is no change about the driver behavior regarding this: it's merely a message asking whether it works or not :)
This laptop doesn't have bluetooth and wifi adapters. I pressed each of the keys shown as "Easy-launch" buttons [#7 on page 7 of the service guide] or Bluetooth [#2 on page 8], or Wireless [#3 on page 8] while looking at 'journalctl -f' and I didn't observe anything happening whatsoever. FWIW: this is a freshly installed Tumbleweed, so I am actually testing with the very first user login in XFCE.
(In reply to Suse User from comment #6) > This laptop doesn't have bluetooth and wifi adapters. > > I pressed each of the keys shown as "Easy-launch" buttons [#7 on page 7 of > the service guide] or Bluetooth [#2 on page 8], or Wireless [#3 on page 8] > while looking at 'journalctl -f' and I didn't observe anything happening > whatsoever. Basically from the kernel POV, it doesn't matter what the service guide gives. The expected behavior is to return a proper key code per each key press. Install evtest package, go to Linux console out of X, and run evtest as root to see whether you get a proper key event. evtest will ask you about the device to test, and you'll need to choose one of them. If the key event looks working, that's fine.
Also, one another feature by this driver: the LED for mail key. If this is present, there should be a corresponding sysfs entry in /sys/class/leds, and you can control the LED there, too. Please check it as well.
Created attachment 811356 [details] evtest and led test Please see the attached output.
Hm, so this doesn't look working on your machine. Please report this to upstream bugzilla, e.g. bugzilla.kernel.org. Or if you don't mind about the lack of these keys, just blacklist the module.
I may try to upstream it. How do I blacklist the module please?
Reported upstream: https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=204291
Put a line blacklist wistron_btns in /etc/modprobe.d/99-local.conf.
As the message suggests: "please report success or failure to eric.piel@tremplin-utc.net". Have you tried doing so? It might the fastest way to actually get an answer.
> Have you tried doing so? Yes. That has been answered in the opening message. > It might the fastest way to actually get an answer. No reply whatsoever (for more than a year).
Hm, no one has touched the upstream driver except for mass updates for quite a long time. However, it seems to be actively maintained. MAINTAINERS file has WISTRON LAPTOP BUTTON DRIVER M: Miloslav Trmac <mitr@volny.cz> S: Maintained F: drivers/input/misc/wistron_btns.c You could try to add him to the upstream bugzilla entry, mail him or add him here.
I am trying to add the email address here but bugzilla is telling me: Bugzilla was unable to make any match at all for one or more of the names and/or email addresses you entered on the previous page. Please go back and try other names or email addresses. CC: mitr@volny.cz did not match anything
And have you tried to send him an email directly?
No response, closing then.
Sorry for the late reply. > And have you tried to send him an email directly? No, I haven't because it seems to me the right way to discuss bugs is on a bug reporting system rather than bothering maintainers in a personal conversation. Please let me know if there is any other info I can provide. The issue is not resolved.
Well, the upstream bugzilla might work, but usually it does not. As is the case here. Mailing the upstream maintainer (with CCing linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org) is a perfect way to report issues, so do not worry.
OK, I have emailed the maintainer. I did not CC linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org because I am not subscribed to that list (and I don't really want to be as kernel list is flooding with a lot of messages). I hope this will work.
Reply from listed maintainer: > I’m afraid I haven’t had any similar hardware for more than a decade. (I should have removed the MAINTAINERS entry, that’s entirely my fault.) > Mirek
Ok, then there is unfortunately nothing we can do. You can blacklist the module as Takashi suggested in comment 10.